Not so long ago arose a question as to the various proofs/labels underwhich Pussers is sold, eg red and blue labels and 40 - 42- 54.5 - 75%. Personally we ran across a vare rare combination - a 40% Red Label - an expression that was disappointing. We later spent time with the Pussers rep in Key Largo who left the impression this issue was an "experiment" that didn't work out. Somehow were left with the notion that this one did not represent the official formula.
At long last, our suspicions have been proven wrong. I recently wrote and received this very informative reply...
Pussers: "Dear Capn Jim,
"Thank you for your inquiry as to the red label at 40% and the formulas for each of our different offerings. Indeed the red label was simply a change in alcohol volume, but I can assure you that the recipe has not deviated in anyway. We are committed to the traditions laid down by the Royal Navy and still use the same tried and true methods of distilling. Over this last year we have changed HQ’s and are now based here in Charleston SC. The distillery and the origins of the blends are still West Indian. The product offerings at 42%, 54.5% and 75% for the RNR and the 15 year old at 40% will be the same. I am sorry that the Red label was not as enjoyable for you and hope that you will long continue to be a fan of Pussers Rum."
"I would like to invite you to look at our website at www.pussersrum.com
Please feel free to browse through and if you have any comments be sure to send anything that you feel might be done to improve or add to it. We are very appreciative of sites such as yours and having read the forums and feedback I would happen to agree with everyone regarding Demerera being the very best for rum. Our tradition requires that one of the key ingredients is rum from the pot stills of Demerara which have consequently helped us to secure some prestigious awards and recognition during 2012.
As an independently owned and operated company we feel it important to continue to get the message out regarding the finest ingredients being sourced and blended and the complexities of the distilling process itself. Thank you for your continued support and appreciation.
If there are any other questions regarding Pussers Rum, please feel free to contact myself.
Yours sincerely, and “Up spirits”
This is now the final answer as far as we're concerned: they are all the same distillate, with the usual purchase being the 47.7% Blue Label. Believe it or not, for years we were able to find this in a full liter for $19.95. Pussers also provided me with a special document "Early History, Facts, Folklore and Nelson". This document is extremely informative and more complete than the website by far.
This to be uploaded and linked, stay tuned...